Fresh Mozzarella Pizzeria | Best Pizza in Sarasota

Most Popular

Try our most popular items.

See More Items

Cannoli

$4.99

Mediterranean Salad

$11.49

Supreme Pizza (Sicilian 16")

$23.29

Kid Pizza

$6.99

Reviews

Order Now

Just stopped In to pick up a large white pizza and an order of garlic knots for my wife and me. We were skeptical because of some of the reviews and price points. The owner was there and was working hard with a smile on his face. He made sure to check the pizza as we ordered it an hour prior to making sure it looked up to par and mentioned they were very busy and he just wanted to make sure everything looked good. People rarely leave positive reviews and are more inclined to leave a negative one so I just wanted to say if some of the reviews (which are mostly good) have you second-guessing I'm here to tell you BOTH the pie and the knots ate absolutely outstanding and I will be returning here often as this was our first time visiting. Thank you fresh mozzarella pizzeria!

Chad

This is the best pizzeria in Sarasota by far. I am very familiar with Florida pizza, and Floridian pizza joints over the years and this right here is classic, beautiful Italian pizza. Fresh flavors. Amazing staff. Do yourself a favor and order.

Graham P.

Best pizza around. I tried getting a picture of the garlic bread, but my kids ate them all before I could get a picture. The pizza was so fresh, and the crust was perfect. I highly recommend it.

Rob A.

We Cater!

Let's take you out of the kitchen and truly enjoy your event. Whether it's an event, business lunch, or just a family gathering. We have a catering option onsite, offsite or delivered to help in the best way we can!

Call 408 607 6032 for more information and options.

Only Fresh Ingredients

We invest in quality ingredients to ensure our customers get the great taste we're famous for. Because we believe that you deserve the best and Homemade Seasonal food is often unbeatable.

Made With Love

Our secret ingredient is passion. Everyone on our team is passionate about making your time with us as great as it can be — from start to finish.

Our Story

Chef Rocco, a southern Italian, has transformed this Sarasota Pizzeria into a neighborhood staple and community favorite! Rocco's belief in practicing daily gratitude and setting an example for his 3 children to always do your best has spread throughout the area. Want to know the secret to finding a good pizzeria? Find out where the locals go! Fresh Mozzarella Pizzeria has experienced an explosion of hundreds of local fans with Rocco's community involvement and passion for making the best pizza.